3rd UPDATE: Fall Out From Total North Sea Gas Leak Intensifies
March 27 2012 - 11:56AM
Dow Jones News
The fall out from Total S.A's North Sea gas leak intensified
Tuesday as the U.K. coast guard maintained exclusion zones around
the area and Royal Dutch Shell PLC (RDSA) evacuated some personnel
and shut down a nearby installation.
The leak, the cause of which is still unknown, has halted around
180,000 barrels equivalent a day of U.K. oil and gas production at
a time when fuel prices are already at all-time highs. Total said
the shut down could continue for several weeks, even in the best
case.
The incident, although handled without casualties and with only
a modest volume of hydrocarbon spilled so far, highlights the
continued risks of offshore oil drilling both in terms of safety
and security of energy supply.
Total confirmed Tuesday that both the Elgin and Franklin fields,
which produce around 130,000 barrels equivalent of oil a day, have
been shut down because of the leak that was first detected Sunday.
Shell said it was also shutting down 50,000 barrels equivalent a
day of oil and gas production at the nearby Shearwater field as a
precaution and to carry out planned maintenance.
Shares in Total fell by 6% Tuesday after the company said it was
studying many options, including the time-consuming operation of
drilling a relief well to intercept the leaking borehole and seal
it with cement.
After its Gulf of Mexico oil spill in 2010, BP PLC (BP) took
three months to drill a relief well under similar reservoir depth
and pressure conditions to the ones Total could face at Elgin.
Total spokesman, Andrew Hogg, rejected comparisons to the
blowout of BP's Gulf of Mexico well, which killed 11 men and
spilled tens of thousands of barrels of oil a day from the
seabed.
"The gas leak is at the platform level, not on the sea floor" as
was the case with Macondo, Hogg said. Earlier reports of "the sea
boiling" with gas released from underground were completely wrong,
he said.
However, Jake Molloy of the offshore workers union OIL RMT said
the incident was potentially the most serious safety risk in the
North Sea since a gas explosion destroyed the Piper Alpha oil rig
in 1988.
Workers on the nearby Shearwater rig, which was partially
evacuated late Monday, reported to him seeing a visible gas cloud
above the Elgin platform, Molloy said. "It's highly explosive gas
and condensate. Total did the right thing evacuating everyone as
soon as possible," he said.
Total believes the gas is leaking from a zone of gas bearing
rock above the G4 well on the Elgin field, which was drilled in
1997 and was shut one year ago, Hogg said.
The company is unsure how much gas is leaking from the field.
The sheen of gas condensate, which is similar to light oil, seen on
the sea in the vicinity of the platform size hasn't grown since
Monday, he said. It is six nautical miles long, representing 24
metric tons of condensate, he added.
The U.K.'s Maritime and Coastguard Agency said it had
established two exclusion zones to enable Total better access to
the leak area. A restriction has been put on flights within a three
mile radius of the incident and ships cannot travel with two
nautical miles of the affected area.
"Any leak we take very seriously and we think the right measures
are being taken to address it," U.K. Energy Minister, Charles
Hendry, told Dow Jones Newswires.
The incident has already hit the U.K. natural gas market. Prices
have risen 2% since the beginning of the week and expected to rise
further if Elgin's supply remains shut in over a long-term period,
a U.K. gas trader said.
The total volume of oil and gas shutdown by the incident is
equivalent to 8.7% of average daily U.K. production for the first
three quarters of 2011, according to data from the Department of
Energy and Climate Change.
The incident has reignited long-standing concerns over the
integrity of infrastructure in the North Sea, where many facilities
are operating long past their intended lives. The Elgin field,
which started operations in 2001, is one the younger fields in a
region where facilities built in the 1970s remain in service.
"This leak also shows how reckless [U.K. Chancellor of the
Exchequer] George Osborne was to hand over billions of pounds of
taxpayers' money to the oil and gas industry just last week to
subsidize deep water drilling," said Vicky Wyatt, senior energy
campaigner for Greenpeace.
A spokesman for the U.K.'s DECC said it is too early to assess
the environmental impact of the leak. "We'll investigate any
particular any incident like this very carefully," the spokesman
said, adding that leaks of gas condensate have typically had fewer
lasting environmental consequences than spills of crude oil.
-By Sarah Kent, Alexis Flynn and Geraldine Amiel, Dow Jones
Newswires; +33 1 40171767; geraldine.amiel@dowjones.com
(James Herron, Selina Williams and Konstantin Rozhnov
contributed to this story.)
-0-
TOTAL (NYSE:TOT)
Historical Stock Chart
From Mar 2025 to Apr 2025
TOTAL (NYSE:TOT)
Historical Stock Chart
From Apr 2024 to Apr 2025